I believe that there is a compelling case for conventional banking to expand into the Producer Credit system for its own benefit as well as that of everyone else. This page will explain why, in detail.
Banks create deposits as promises of legal tender on demand.
A deposit is not an asset to a bank.
Nonetheless, banks MUST attract deposits
This is the explanation.
1. A checking account deposit means the demand for legal tender the bank doesn't have has been indefinitely deferred. A term savings deposit means that the depositor very probably won't be asking for that legal tender or transferring that deposit to another bank for the definite term of the deposit. The safest "deferred demand" for legal tender is a long term savings deposit and banks pay interest for that certainty.
2. An incoming deposit from another bank balances out against a deposit outgoing to another bank. The banks just trade liabilities to their depositors and the net result is the banks don't owe each other anything.
To succeed at creating money as promises of legal tender that the banks don't have requires that banks receive an equal amount of these promises back as deposits. Therefore, a banks' ability to create money as loans without being in debt to other banks, is dependent on the deposits it receives.
To attract long term savings deposits, banks must offer competitive rates of interest. These rates of interest are currently far below the rate of inflation. Therefore...
Savers steadily lose purchasing power.
In real purchasing power,10% annual inflation means half of our savings evaporate every 7.3 years.
Banks could, instead of term deposits at interest,
The savers would pay for Producer Credits with bank credit or legal tender.
The results would be:
1.The money received by the Producer would be SPENT into circulation immediately to fund production instead of locked up in savings or lent a second time.
2. The Producer would receive current value for the conventional money.
3. The money spent would be deposited in a transaction account on which the bank pays no interest.
4. The money deposited in the transaction account still serves the two essential purposes listed above.
In the new expanded system, the banks would attract transaction deposits in Producer accounts with offers of inflation-proofed Producer Credits to be sold for bank credit to savers. The savers would get the "dividend" the Producer offers in real goods or services, instead of the bank piling on exponentially compounding interest in promises of legal tender it doesn't have. The banks would get a proportionate increase in Producer transaction accounts that would still serve to net out their liabilities to each other
This is advantageous to all concerned in seven distinct ways
1. Society, the Economy and the current Banking System
According to the analysis presented, twice-lent money is what creates the grow-or-collapse mathematical trap that plagues the world. Eliminating savings as bank credit would solve the core instability problem of our current money system by returning bank credit money to circulation where it could be earned rather than having to be borrowed a second time to pay off the debt that created it.
This would avoid the creation of Perpetual Debt and make shrinkage of the bank credit supply possible without causing mathematically inevitable defaults.
The "store of value" function of bank credit savings would be transferred into the Producer Credits. The result would be that much more conventional money would be available as a "medium of exchange", stimulating the economy and making banking far more stable.
2. Banks #1
Until the practice caught on, this would be a competitive advantage for participating banks.
To the extent that business borrowing of conventional funds would be replaced by Producer Credits, banks would lose that interest income. They would also lose the risk of default on what is often unsecured debt based on projected income, and the need for 8% capital adequacy on that credit.
3. Banks #2
This Producer Credit brokerage business has many potential new sources of income (see 7). Entry into this business has already been recommended in detail, to the City of London in this report. The implementation recommended here would expand the scope of credit brokerage far beyond that envisioned in the report.
Banks as Producer Credit Brokers
All of the above are services today's banks could expand into that would ensure the smooth functioning of the new system and the security of the participants. Those services would most certainly be worthy of fees.
There seem to be win-win advantages for everyone.
Producer Credits would be a mathematical "relief valve" for the current system. The expansion into Producer Credits would enable the current system to become sustainable and stable and preserve itself.